Plainville Skips Nativity Scene Display, Sparks Heated Backlash

UPDATE: The absence of a nativity scene in Plainville this holiday season has ignited intense controversy. Officials announced that the display, a tradition for over 25 years, will not be put up in Veterans Memorial Park, leading to significant public outcry.

In a series of Facebook posts, the Plainville Republicans criticized the decision, claiming that town officials, particularly under Democratic leadership, sought legal advice regarding the display’s constitutionality. The Republicans argue that no formal complaints prompted this review and that the Town Council was sidelined in the decision-making process. “We are disappointed that proper protocol regarding chain of command was not followed,” stated one post, which garnered nearly 500 reactions and 150 comments.

The legal opinion from town attorney Morris Borea, prompted by discussions about a Christmas tree display at the town library, raises serious questions about the legality of a standalone nativity scene. “The research indicated to me that the scene by itself would likely raise a serious issue with regard to the Establishment Clause under the First Amendment,” Borea explained to the Courant.

Borea highlighted that a nativity scene on public property could imply government endorsement of Christianity. “Under our constitution, government isn’t supposed to endorse one view over another,” he emphasized. His analysis, dated December 21, suggests two possible solutions: incorporating the nativity into a larger, secular holiday display or establishing a public forum policy allowing community groups to place various holiday displays.

“Plainville may display the nativity scene this year only if it is part of a broader, inclusive holiday display,” Borea concluded in his legal opinion. This guidance aims to avoid violating the Establishment Clause and potential legal actions against the town.

Republicans proposed that a balanced solution could have involved adding secular decorations to the nativity scene, thus preserving the tradition while adhering to legal standards. They also mentioned that the Town Council plans to meet to discuss potential policy changes in the near future.

The lack of response from key officials adds to the urgency of this unfolding situation. Emails sent to Town Manager Michael Paulhus and the chair of the Plainville Democratic Town Committee seeking comments went unanswered, leaving many residents in the dark about the council’s next steps.

As public sentiment continues to grow, many residents are voicing their support for the nativity scene, underscoring its significance to the community. The debate raises broader questions about the intersection of tradition, religion, and governance in public spaces.

Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story and the upcoming Town Council meeting that could shape Plainville’s holiday displays for years to come.