Off-Broadway’s “Romy & Michele” Musical Bombs at Stage 42

UPDATE: The Off-Broadway musical adaptation of “Romy & Michele” has officially opened at Stage 42, and early reviews are dire. Critics have labeled the production as a disappointing and lackluster take on the cult classic, leaving audiences questioning its relevance and charm.

In a stark contrast to the beloved 1997 film, this musical iteration fails to capture the essence of the original story. It stars Laura Bell Bundy and Kara Lindsay, yet critics describe their performances as uninspired, lacking the chemistry that made the film memorable. The show first debuted in Seattle in 2017 and has now made its way to New York, but it appears to have missed the mark.

Audience reactions have been swift. Many express disappointment, likening the experience to “watching ‘Pretty Woman’ 36 times” or enduring an awkward high school reunion filled with success stories from former classmates. The show struggles to engage viewers, with a score by Gwendolyn Sanford and Brandon Jay that fails to resonate, described as “generic Broadway pop” without any memorable tunes.

The plot follows the same premise as the film, where two friends invent fictitious identities to impress their high school classmates. However, critics argue that the production lacks the humor and depth needed to make it engaging. Instead of offering new insights or comedic value, the musical seems trapped in a repetitive cycle, unable to break free from its cinematic roots.

A standout performance comes from Jordan Kai Burnett, playing the goth rival Heather, but even this bright spot can’t save the show. The production, directed by Kristin Hanggi, is criticized for its chaotic visual style, which feels more like a mishmash than a cohesive experience.

With ticket prices soaring into the triple digits, many are left wondering if this adaptation was a necessary venture. The consensus among critics is clear: “Romy & Michele The Musical” is an awkward reunion that fails to connect with audiences.

As the show continues its run at Stage 42, theatergoers are left to decide if they will take the plunge and witness this much-anticipated yet disheartening adaptation. With more reviews expected in the coming days, the fate of this production hangs in the balance.

Stay tuned for updates as this story develops.