Kayla Nicole’s Halloween Costume Sparks Speculation About Travis Kelce

Kayla Nicole’s recent Halloween costume has caught the attention of fans, leading to speculation that she aimed a subtle jab at her ex, NFL player Travis Kelce, and his current partner, singer Taylor Swift. On October 31, 2025, Nicole, 33, posted an image on Instagram showcasing her outfit inspired by the iconic singer Toni Braxton, specifically recreating Braxton’s look from the music video for her hit song “He Wasn’t Man Enough.”

The timing and choice of costume sparked lively discussions among followers, many interpreting it as a pointed comment directed at Kelce, 36. One commenter remarked, “The shade is real 😂,” while another added, “This is how you have the last laugh.. ☺️👏🏽.” The song, released in 2000, features lyrics that seem to reflect themes of empowerment and moving on from a relationship, including lines like, “Listen, girl / Who do you think I am? / Don’t you know that he was my man? / But I chose to let him go.”

Fans of both Kelce and Swift have also drawn connections to Swift’s recent track “Opalite,” which some believe includes a veiled reference to Nicole. In the song, Swift, 35, sings, “You couldn’t understand it / Why you felt alone / You were in it for real / She was in her phone.” Some listeners have pointed to a resurfaced clip of Kelce and Nicole during their relationship, in which Kelce appears to express frustration over Nicole’s phone usage at dinner, saying, “Get off your phone. … You’re not even drinking your wine anymore, can we go?”

Nicole’s social media activity has kept fans speculating about her feelings towards Swift and her former relationship. Following the release of Swift’s album on October 3, which includes “Opalite,” Nicole posted a throwback clip from America’s Next Top Model featuring contestant Eva Marcille. In the clip, host Tyra Banks asks Marcille how she compares herself to other girls, to which Marcille confidently responds, “I don’t compare myself to other girls. I’m Eva. I’m no comparison to anyone else.” Although Nicole did not provide context for her post, many fans speculated that it could relate to the ongoing narrative between the three individuals.

As the internet buzzes with interpretations of Nicole’s costume and social media activity, it’s clear that the intertwining lives of these public figures continue to captivate their audiences. Each new post and performance adds another layer to the ongoing story, keeping fans engaged and eager for more updates.

With the Halloween costume and associated commentary, Nicole has certainly made headlines, demonstrating how fashion and social media can ignite conversations about celebrity relationships and past dynamics.